Which States Require You to Have Health Insurance?

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) transformed healthcare in the United States, making health insurance more accessible and affordable. While the federal government repealed the ACA's individual mandate penalty in 2019, several states have implemented their own mandates requiring residents to maintain health insurance coverage. These state-level mandates aim to reduce uninsured rates, improve public health outcomes, and fund state-specific healthcare programs.

In this article, we’ll provide a detailed overview of which states require you to have health insurance, the penalties for noncompliance, and how employers can support employees in meeting these mandates through innovative solutions like health reimbursement arrangements (HRAs).

What Is the Individual Mandate?

The individual mandate was a key provision of the ACA that required Americans to maintain minimum essential coverage (MEC) or pay a federal tax penalty. Its purpose was to create balanced risk pools by encouraging healthy individuals to enroll in coverage, offsetting costs for higher-risk individuals.

Although Congress repealed the federal penalty in 2017 (effective 2019), some states have enacted their own mandates to uphold healthcare coverage levels. These mandates typically apply to residents who can afford coverage but choose not to purchase it.

States That Require Health Insurance

Currently, five states and the District of Columbia enforce individual mandates requiring residents to maintain health insurance. Let’s examine each state’s requirements:

‍

1. New Jersey

New Jersey enacted its Health Insurance Market Preservation Act in 2018. Residents must maintain MEC or face penalties during tax filing unless they qualify for exemptions such as financial hardship or unaffordable coverage.

• Penalty calculation for not having health Insurance plans in New Jersey is based on household size and income, with a cap set at the average annual premium for a bronze-tier plan available in the state.

2. California

California reinstated its individual mandate in 2020. Residents are required to have MEC for themselves and their dependents or pay penalties. Exemptions include hardships, unaffordable coverage, or membership in healthcare-sharing ministries.

• Penalty Calculation: The higher of $900 per adult ($450 per child) or 2.5% of household income exceeding the state filing threshold applies for those without health Insurance plans in California.

3. Rhode Island

Rhode Island implemented its mandate in January 2020. Residents must maintain qualifying health Insurance plans in Rhode Island unless exempt due to hardship or unaffordability.

• Penalty Calculation: The greater of $695 per adult ($347.50 per child) or 2.5% of household income minus exemptions.

4. Massachusetts

Massachusetts has enforced an individual mandate since 2006 under its Health Care Reform Law. Residents must maintain minimum creditable coverage (MCC) throughout the year unless exempt due to affordability issues or financial hardship.

• Penalty Calculation: When considering Health Insurance plans in Massachusetts, the penalty calculation is based on age, income, and family size, and is capped at half the cost of the lowest-priced self-only plan available through ConnectorCare.

5. District of Columbia

Washington D.C.’s mandate began in January 2020. Residents must have MEC or pay penalties calculated based on household income and family size. For those searching for Health Insurance plans in District of Columbia, understanding the penalty calculation is crucial: the higher of $745 per adult ($372.50 per child) or 2.5% of income above D.C.’s tax filing threshold applies.

6. Vermont

Vermont encourages residents to maintain coverage by offering a wide range of health Insurance plans in Vermont through its state-based marketplace, Vermont Health Connect. Residents can compare and choose from various qualified plans, including options for individuals, families, and small businesses, with most enrollees eligible for financial assistance to lower their costs. While state law requires Vermonters to have health insurance, no financial penalties are imposed for those who do not comply with this requirement.

Why States Enforce Individual Mandates

State-level mandates serve several important functions:

• Reduce Uninsured Rates: Encouraging residents to enroll ensures fewer individuals go without necessary medical care.
• Support State Healthcare Programs: Penalties fund reinsurance programs and subsidies for low-income residents.
• Improve Health Outcomes: Broader access to preventive care reduces long-term healthcare costs.
• Financial Stability: Mandates help stabilize state insurance markets by ensuring balanced risk pools.

‍

How Employers Can Help Employees Comply

Employers play a critical role in helping employees meet state mandates through HRAs like Qualified Small Employer HRAs (QSEHRAs) or Individual Coverage HRAs (ICHRAs). These employer-funded benefits reimburse employees tax-free for individual health insurance premiums and other qualifying medical expenses.

Benefits of HRAs:

• Flexibility: Employees can select plans tailored to their needs.
• Cost Savings: Employers control costs by setting reimbursement limits.
• Compliance Assistance: HRAs require employees to maintain MEC, satisfying state mandates.

Employers offering HRAs should educate employees on how these benefits interact with premium tax credits available through marketplaces.

Additionally, employers should stay informed about reporting requirements in states with individual mandates. For example:

• In California, employers may need to submit employee coverage data annually.
• In Massachusetts, employers must verify that employees meet MCC standards through ConnectorCare documentation.
  Failure to comply with these reporting requirements may result in penalties for employers.

Key Considerations for Businesses

Businesses operating across multiple states should carefully assess how state-level mandates impact their workforce:

1. Identify State-Specific Regulations: Determine which states impose individual mandates and their corresponding reporting requirements.
2. Educate Employees: Provide clear communication about state-specific health insurance requirements.
3. Offer Flexible Benefits: Implement HRAs or other customizable solutions that align with state laws while meeting employee needs.
4. Monitor Compliance Deadlines: Ensure timely submission of required documentation to avoid penalties.

By proactively addressing these considerations, businesses can support their employees while maintaining compliance with evolving healthcare regulations.

Conclusion

While federal penalties for not having health insurance no longer apply, several states continue enforcing individual mandates to promote broader healthcare access and fund critical programs. Understanding your state’s requirements is essential to avoid penalties and ensure compliance.

Employers can play a pivotal role by offering flexible HRAs that empower employees to choose individualized plans while meeting state regulations. By prioritizing coverage and education around healthcare benefits, businesses can foster healthier workforces while supporting compliance with state laws.

State-level mandates reflect an ongoing commitment to ensuring all Americans have access to quality healthcare—an essential step toward building healthier communities across the nation.

Read More - State-by-state guide to health insurance marketplaces